17 / 20

As pilot-in-command, what should you do if the controller gives an instruction or clearance that you feel is inappropriate?

  • A

    Follow the instruction or clearance, but file a report after landing

  • B

    Request an amended instruction or clearance

  • C

    Ignore the instruction or clearance

  • D

    Accept that air traffic control is in charge, and follow the instruction or clearance

As the pilot-in-command (PIC), you are the final authority for the safe operation of your aircraft. If an instruction or clearance from Air Traffic Control (ATC) is inappropriate, unsafe, or causes you to deviate from regulations, you are responsible for refusing it and requesting an amended one.

  • If you cannot safely comply with an instruction, consider stating "Unable." It is often helpful to briefly explain why (e.g., weather, terrain, or aircraft performance) and state your requested alternative.
  • If you are merely unsure or confused by a clearance, you should immediately request clarification from ATC before taking any action.

Your Notes (not visible to others)



This question has appeared on the real examination, you can find the related countries below.

Keyboard Shortcut Use Keyboard Shortcuts